I agree. I've been fighting both sides for a while. And if you notice, I'll try to give the benefit of the doubt to the other side when necessary to keep from losing support. (I posted the high side #'s: $15-20k)
Based on my recent tax statement, I can't possibly say my property values have gone down as a result of alcohol. But a 2.2% increase isn't significant either. So from my viewpoint, neither argument is accurate.